Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

SHIFT turns the Rock into a canvas

Group celebrates International Blasphemy Rights Day

Published: Thursday, September 30, 2010

Updated: Sunday, October 3, 2010 13:10

shift

“Blasphemy”: Students take permanent markers to the Rock after the Secular Humanists for Inquiry and FreeThought painted the landmark white, creating a forum for controversial commentary. (Jai Broome/The Daily Northwestern)

Comments about Sarah Palin, Zeus and Darth Vader decorated the Rock on Thursday after members of Secular Humanists for Inquiry and FreeThought painted it white in honor of International Blasphemy Rights Day and invited students to write on it.

Quotes from the Bible and an image of a "dead zombie Jesus" adorned the campus landmark, along with phrases ranging from "All NU students are conceited" to "Go Packers."

Some of the writings attacked fraternity and sorority life. One student grabbed a marker and quickly scrawled on the surface, "What's up with all the bees?"

Some waxed philosophical: "There's no secret to life," one anonymous author opined. "We're all just chillin'."

SHIFT members stood by the Rock all day encouraging those walking by to write anything on the Rock with different colored markers. Many chose to draw profane images and write four-letter words.

"We're all pretty good at blaspheming," said Harry Noble, the group's events coordinator. "We figured we'd give the rest of the campus a try."

While several writings attacked religion, no one appeared to attempt to draw the Prophet Muhammad — a controversial action that has been associated with SHIFT since last spring.

In May, members of the group chalked images of the Prophet Muhammad around campus to "make a statement that we support the freedom of expression, specifically that we stand behind South Park," SHIFT President Cassy Byrne said at the time, in the wake of an uproar over a censored South Park episode. Drawing Muhammad challenges deeply held beliefs regarding idolatry in Islam.

In the ensuing controversy, NU President Morton O. Schapiro called the drawings "a mistake."

International Blasphemy Rights Day commemorates the anniversary of a Danish newspaper's publishing of cartoons depicting the Prophet Muhammad in 2005. It is promoted by the Center for Inquiry On Campus's "Campaign for Free Expression." The campaign instructed students to use the day "to support free speech, support the right to criticize and satirize religion and to oppose any resolutions or laws … that discourage or inhibit free speech of any kind," according to its website.

Some reacted to the celebration of blasphemy in today's political and religious culture.

"Sometimes it is more courageous to be respectful than it is to blaspheme," said Rahma Bavelaar, a fourth-year graduate student in religious studies

Members of SHIFT did not encourage students to draw or write anything specific.

"We kind of just made the canvas," said Geoff Minger, SHIFT's vice president, adding that the Rock now featured "quite a few wieners."

By 4 p.m., Noble estimated more than 100 students had drawn on the Rock.

"We're running out of space, frankly," the Weinberg senior said. "People have been having a lot of fun."

Members of SHIFT's executive board came up with the idea to turn the Rock into a canvas for free speech at a conference over the summer, Byrne said. The Rock is "really the centerpiece of campus," the Weinberg junior said.

One student who stopped to write on the Rock, Emily Kaht, said she was surprised at some of the images and phrases students had chosen to write.

"I'm kind of disappointed that NU students, on the whole, are so profane and judgmental," the Weinberg sophomore said.

Kaht wrote two phrases on the Rock, she said - one that said "Rachel isn't good enough for Finn," a reference to the show Glee and the phrase, "God is real," to which someone added "-ly gay." Kaht said she was offended by the addition and planned to cross it out.

Though some students were offended, SHIFT members said the day was a success. The group plans to repeat the event next year.

"It looked perfect," Byrne said. "It was exactly as we envisioned it."

— lark@u.northwestern.edu

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

12 comments

Anonymous
Wed Oct 6 2010 18:33
I was VERY offended by the "dead zombie Jesus," and I agree that it isn't right that it is "okay" to blaspheme about Christianity but not Islam. I only made the comment about Mohammad because that was something the SHIFT members themselves did. The "dead zombie Jesus" and other offensive things on the Rock this year, however, were done mostly by non-SHIFT members. Since so many of the comments are bashing SHIFT for having poor taste, I was merely trying to point out that in this case, it was mostly non-SHIFT members who were being offensive.

But yes, as I said, I did find the "dead zombie Jesus" (and other insults to Christianity) very offensive.

Anonymous
Mon Oct 4 2010 17:51
Were you equally offended by this year's image of a "dead zombie Jesus" ??

If the "community" feels it acceptable to blaspheme Jesus, how can it claim to be "offended" when someone depicts Mohammed? I mean, if blasphemy is the goal, then why is Mohammed all of a sudden so sacrosanct and why are depictions of him, according to Pres. Shapiro, "a mistake".

Hey Pres! How about commenting on "dead zombie Jesus?"

Why does Islam get preferential treatment? Could it be that Christianity (and Catholicism, in particular) has been fair game with respect to open academic ridicule for the past four decades? Will it take enlightened society that long to feel comfortable blaspheming Mohammed?

If we're gonna blaspheme, then lets blaspheme. Fair?

Just asking....

Anonymous
Sat Oct 2 2010 22:25
Keep in mind that it's not SHIFT's fault that so many students chose to write offensive and stupid things. They just painted the Rock white and handed out markers. The vast majority of the comments on the Rock were written by non-SHIFT members.

I do disagree with their campaign to draw Muhammad last year, though. THAT was insulting and tasteless.

Anonymous
Sat Oct 2 2010 20:59
A bunch of cowards. Using Blasphemy Rights Day to make mindless statements, because they can't conjure up anything clever to say in a face-to-face argument. They claim to be so open-minded, but it is evident that they are the most close-minded and judgmental group on campus.
Anonymous
Sat Oct 2 2010 19:19
There is seriously no point in antagonizing people of other beliefs or religions. Sounds like a group full of poor taste.
Anonymous
Sat Oct 2 2010 10:46
Wow, you guys are so uptight! This was actually really fun...
Anonymous
Sat Oct 2 2010 09:26
Don't blaspheme Mohammend, though...every other religion is fair game...but not Islam....such hypocrisy even amongst those who choose to blaspheme.
Anonymous
Fri Oct 1 2010 22:26
Yeah that Glee thing was pretty gay
Anonymous
Fri Oct 1 2010 13:18
Oh, go them. Way to show the world that you're mature.

Sooner or later, they're going to have to realize that free speech doesn't mean saying negative things about other people just because you feel like it. I like how, last year, they said that SHIFT is here because of the negative stereotypes against atheists and free-thinking whatever activists.. but they're actually doing quite a good job fitting into that negative stereotypes. Way to show us that you're capable of being full functioning citizens in the real world, giving the finger to opposers and cursing off religion in general.

Or maybe that's the reaction looking for - they want see how far they can go. I'm not sure what this is accomplishing, except for letting douchebags be themselves. I'm pretty sure that's not what the founding fathers had in mind in terms of free speech.

Anonymous
Fri Oct 1 2010 12:26
What was the purpose of this again, SHI(F)T? What bullshift.
Anonymous
Fri Oct 1 2010 09:28
Here is another example of people with too much time on their hands and not enough good taste.
Anonymous
Fri Oct 1 2010 04:38
Cassy Byrne is a junior, not a senior.






log out