College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

LeBuhn: Tossing our two-faced reputation

By Mac LeBuhn

Print this article

Published: Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, November 10, 2009

For a while now, I’ve had a knot in my stomach about my favorite furry feline, Willie the Wildcat. Northwestern has been asking Willie to perform double duty for the past few decades, and it sounds like Willie’s purgatory might be coming to an end soon. I realized this after reading the framework for the University Strategic Plan released last week.

Fortunately for Willie, one of the University’s goals was to “clarify Northwestern’s unique value proposition” over the next 10 years — in other words, figure out just what NU represents, which means Willie finally can be the mascot for just one Northwestern.

After all, we have Willie the Big Ten Wildcat and Willie the Midwest-Ivy Wildcat. Trying to do both roles has been really hard on Willie — it’s tough trying to act like the mascot for Indiana University half the time and Yale University the other half.

One day, you might find Willie combing his mane (or whatever it is wildcats do to prepare) before an athletic event to represent NU as a Big Ten school. Willie works his poor little costumed paws to the stuffing just to try to keep NU students from ditching the game for a couple of 3 p.m. Big Cups at The Keg. This is tough work.

When the University hasn’t asked him to represent NU as a Big Ten school, they ask him to put on his academic face. Then, you can find Willie stalking through the halls of Kresge and Tech, doing some quiet, supportive back flips in a classroom during midterms. (If you’ve never noticed, he’s very discreet. He knows how distracting that might be.)

Much like Willie, NU itself has a stake in deciding what it stands for. While Willie’s done a pretty good job at straddling the fence, NU’s performance has left more to be desired.

The Plan poses several questions about these issues: “What culture does Northwestern aspire to have? Should we develop a common experience for students?” Students who complain about their NU experience ought to weigh in on these questions. After all, the answer that will be eventually developed is significant.

If the outcome of the University Strategic Plan recommends NU focuses on its academic, research-oriented side as its “unique value proposition,” that’s all well and good, just as it is if NU chooses the social, Big Ten aspect. Both commitments will carry a host of changes that should be pursued.

The fact is, NU’s attempt at wearing both masks means neither is worn all that well. It is commendable that NU is trying to tackle this problem, but I just hope it commits to one understanding and pursue it fully.

But, of course, the real reason I wrote this column was for the well-being of my dear friend Willie. Don’t worry, Willie, one day soon, you’ll know whether you’re rooting for a Big Ten university or an academic powerhouse. This one-university, two-Willie purgatory will be over soon, big guy.

Weinberg senior Mac LeBuhn can be reached at mac.lebuhn@gmail.com.

Comments

9 comments
M
Wed Nov 11 2009 09:20
Here's an even better question--can we have a great athletic program, excel in academics, AND practice common human decency? Some of these comments are unnecessarily mean and spiteful. It's enough to just say "I don't agree with you and here's why." You don't have to call someone an idiot or tell them not to "suck so hard." I, for one, am slightly ashamed that even though I go to a school that's both athletically and academically great, the people in it can be so nasty to each other.
LEAVE ALREADY
Tue Nov 10 2009 22:43
Please transfer, legacy.
C. Lever
Tue Nov 10 2009 20:18
You're the best journalist ever! Your ideas are unique and new! And so very valid! It's a good thing you thought of them before we, heaven forbid, became like Michigan University, Berkeley, or worse, Duke or Stanford! It would be incomprehensible.

Actually, no more sarcasm. You're an idiot and a hack and your columns are generally entertaining but verbose journalistic refuse. Please try not to suck so hard in the future.

Dan
Tue Nov 10 2009 20:17
Here's a metaphor for you: Why promote a culture that says you can excel in many things when you can just spread the idea that its better to be good at only ONE thing!? Now THAT is a great way to educate upcoming generations of leaders!

Mac - you might be a decent writer, but you should really think about your argument before you actually voice it in the future. Come on, man.

Your name
Tue Nov 10 2009 19:55
Who needs facts when you have metaphors!
Alum '09
Tue Nov 10 2009 19:48
There is no reason that NU can't be one of the nation's top universities and also have a rich sports culture. The notion that they are mutually exclusive is preposterous. For instance, at President Shapiro's former school, Williams College, they are a top-ranked college and also have a distinct sports culture despite the fact that they are a Division III school. What about schools like Notre Dame and Stanford?

Ugh, there are so many other flaws in this column that I'm just going to stop writing. This is a terrible, terrible article.

Kevin
Tue Nov 10 2009 19:38
Just to clarify, considering that NU athletics are arguably at its peak right now (NU Football experiencing a renaissance since 1995, #1 ranked women's tennis, highly ranked wrestling and softball teams, an incredibly improving women's basketball program, and a men's basketball program ready to turn the corner) are you saying that this is a result of sacrificing our academic prestige? Last I checked, nothing has changed in terms of NU's academic standing around the country and the sports here continue to get better--I just think Mac is, like many students, someone who assumes the sports teams are bad here and probably thinks Tyrell Sutton is still our start football player. Go to a game one day, then read about the incredible research going on at NU, then tell me if we need to 'sacrifice' one of the two facets, because it seems to me we're doing just fine, Mac just knows nothing about athletics here.
Your name
Tue Nov 10 2009 17:35
this was a really cool article, a really awesome article about willie the wildcat, i love the stereotypes you made about the university and northwestern, it is awesome
Your name
Tue Nov 10 2009 08:07
you're smart :)






log out